BY: COLIN BISH, SPORTS DEPARTMENT
It’s a beautiful time in our nation.
Economic uncertainty? Crazy political dogma? Fear of the future? Means nothing when college football is back in session.
As I’m nearing 22 years of age, some would consider it harmful that I’d ignore real-world problems to focus heavily on a sport. I’d say you’re right, but there’s a time and place to focus on the outside world and not my condensed reality where college football is essential as air. But I choose the latter every time, in every place.
Anyways, college football has concluded its first week back, and there’s a lot of interesting storylines to focus on. I’ll go over four good, four bad and four ugly things I saw from this week and bring up four questions for Week 2.
The Good:
Tommy Castellanos Stands on Business
Back in late June, Castellanos, who transferred to Florida State from Boston College, made a bold callout of Alabama when he said, “They don’t have Nick Saban to save them. I just don’t see them stopping me.”
Naturally, everyone wrote him off as delusional. There’s no way Bama could lose to a Seminoles team that won two games last year, right? Well, college football is where the craziest is common.
Florida State took the Tide to school, dominating in a 31-17 upset victory. The ‘Noles took control in the trenches, a shocking development considering Alabama’s prowess in developing linemen. But FSU stood tall, harassing quarterback Ty Simpson and dominating the ground game, all four touchdowns coming via the run game.
Castellanos didn’t go quietly, either, totalling 230 yards of offense including two beautiful deep balls to Jaylin Lucas and Squirrel White. The past is the past for Florida State; if they can play close to that level we saw Saturday afternoon, expect the Seminoles to be a legitimate College Football Playoff contender.
Ohio State, LSU silence the defensive doubters
It’s been a long time since LSU has had a truly vaunted defense. Ohio State was fantastic last year, but lost so much of their talent, especially on the defensive line. Going up against Heisman hopeful Cade Klubnik for Clemson and the uber-hyped Arch Manning, respectively, many expected these games to be shootouts. Not on their watch.
Ohio State, under new defensive leadership with Matt Patricia, was ready for the young Manning, flustering him and forcing multiple errant throws. The new-look defensive line held very well against a talented backfield of CJ Baxter Jr. and Tre Wisner. Equally impressive was LSU, going up against a loaded Clemson offense. Harold Perkins Jr. led the way with five tackles, 1.5 for loss and a sack while the Tigers secondary forced six pass deflections off a talented receiving core.
Maybe they are DBU, after all.
Miami kicker Carter Davis, the unsung hero
Many eyes were on the fantastic top-10 matchup between Notre Dame and Miami; a rivalry renewed with multiple question marks. How would Carson Beck perform for the Canes? Can CJ Carr lead the Irish as a redshirt freshman quarterback? Will Notre Dame’s defense remain as stout as it was last year?
But one player caught my eye that not many would have expected: Carter Davis. A transfer from Florida Atlantic, Davis beat out former Texas kicker Bert Auburn for the starting job. However, Davis made four out of 11 field goals in his three years at Boca Raton. Many figured this would be a struggle for Davis, but it was quite the opposite.
Davis made all five of his kicks, three extra points and two field goals, including the winning field goal with a minute to go. Beck did have a great game and Carr looks to be the guy for the Irish going forward, but I was most impressed by Davis in this scenario. A guy with less than stellar results coming into this game came out as a key component in the win for Mario Cristobal’s squad.
Kent State breaks their skid
The Golden Flashes have been in the basement of college football for over two years. Dating back to 2023, they went on a 21-game loss streak. They were in danger of losing a 22nd consecutive game after going behind 17-14 in the fourth quarter of their game against Merrimack.
But the Flashes weren’t going to be denied history, as junior receiver Da’Realyst Clark (yes that is his name) took the following kickoff 100 yards to the house. Kent State would hold on to their 21-17 lead and win the game, finally breaking the tumultuous loss streak. KSU’s Cade Wolford scored the other two touchdowns of the game, a 30-yard pass in the second quarter and a 79-yarder in the third. A great start for first-year coach Mark Carney, and his team is rewarded in Week 2 with a trip to Lubbock to take on #24 Texas Tech. Good luck, Flashes!
The Bad:
Arch Manning’s hype train hits a speed-bump
No college football player was more talked about, more heralded, and more electric than Arch Manning. The kid with NFL Hall of Fame lineage was about to get his first taste of real action, against the defending national champions, Ohio State. Multiple scouts attended the game, many of their eyes on the potential number-one pick. But the debut didn’t go as expected.
Manning finished 17 of 30 passing for 170 yards, one touchdown and one interception. He also missed many key throws, including a third-down pass in the fourth quarter that could’ve set the Longhorns up for the tying score. Does this mean that Manning is a fraud? Absolutely not; he’s going up against an uber-talented defense, manned by studs like Caleb Downs and Sonny Styles, and a defensive coordinator with NFL experience in Matt Patricia. Arch will rebound, but that doesn’t mean the opening act wasn’t a flop considering all the preseason hype.
Love is NOT in the air in the 305
If not for the otherworldly campaign of one Ashton Jeanty, a lot of people would have been more aware of Jeremiyah Love. The Saint Louis native was the primary offensive cog in Notre Dame’s playoff run, rushing for over 1000 yards and 17 touchdowns on almost seven yards a carry.
With Jeanty in the NFL, Love was clearly the best returning running back in college football. But his hype ran into a roadblock or, rather, a hurricane. A lot of them. Miami stifled Love all game long, as he finished with 33 yards on 10 carries. Granted, the Miami defensive line is loaded with talent like Rueben Bain Jr. and Akheem Mesidor. Still, it’s a disappointing start, nonetheless. The Irish have a bye week before they play Texas A&M in their home opener on the 13th, so we’ll see if Love can get a bounceback against solid competition.
Dabo’s offensive crew stagnates at home
Clemson came into this year with potential national title aspirations, headed by a nasty offense. Duel-threat quarterback Cade Klubnik led the charge, backed by a nasty receiving core of Bryant Wesco Jr., T.J. Moore and Antonio Williams.
Yet, this offensive juggernaut fell silent against the OTHER Tigers, that being LSU. Klubnik was shut down, completing only 50% of his passes for 230 yards, no touchdowns and a pick. While Wesco Jr. and Moore had solid games, Williams exited after suffering a hamstring injury and didn’t return. Williams’ absence may have affected the offense’s flow, but the run game is what really suffered. LSU held Clemson to 31 yards on the ground, compared to LSU’s 108 rushing yards.
While Clemson isn’t out of the race yet, they’ll need Williams back for Klubnik and especially need to fix the run game. There’s only so much the passing game can do for you.
Belichick’s feeling baby blue against TCU
Like the little rhyme? Sorry, I promise I’ll never do that again.
The greatest head coach in NFL history has made his way to college, taking over the helm at Chapel Hill. Packed to the brim with Heels fans, on Monday primetime, in front of legends like Michael Jordan, Randy Moss and Roy Williams. But the spectacle couldn’t hide the poor performance from North Carolina.
After taking a 7-0 lead in the first quarter, TCU found its groove and stomped the Heels (ha!) 48-14. The Frogs defense looked elite, while the offensive trio of Josh Hoover, Kevorian Barnes and Jordan Dwyer ran roughshod on Belichick’s squad.
Now, why doesn’t this go in the ugly tier? Because I expected TCU to win. They finished a very underrated squad in 2024 and have a great team that could make some noise this year. And I also don’t expect Bill to transform North Carolina into a superpower immediately; the Patriots dynasty took time to establish, too. Even though I didn’t expect this big a loss, I’m not fully panicking on Belichick yet, but it’s also not the best look in the world, either.
The Ugly:
Low Tide; Is Bama finally finished?
“High Tide!” “It’s ‘Roll Tide.’” Well now it’s just “Low Tide.” Alabama had some intrigue coming into 2025 under year 2 of Kalen DeBoer. With a solid defense returning, a new quarterback in Ty Simpson and the best wide receiver in college football NOT named Jeremiah Smith, Ryan Williams, some figured they could maintain the same elite consistency. Especially against Florida State, even while on the road, a team that won two games last year.
Well, the ‘Noles thrashed the Tide, 31-17. Undoubtedly the worst loss I’ve ever seen Alabama take. A program that prided on dominance in the trenches was bullied, both on offense and defense, by an FSU squad who hasn’t had the best recent track record of premier offensive and defensive linemen. At least not to Bama’s level. The offense looked anemic outside of Germie Bernard and Simpson, and the defense was even worse.
When Saban was around, I remember the sentiment that whenever they lost was, “Well, they’re Bama; they’ll be back.” But like Tommy Castellanos said: Saban’s not there to save them anymore. And I’m not too sure about the Tide going forward.
Nico Iamaleava bets on himself… for a bad defense
One of the biggest storylines from last offseason was Nico Iamaleava’s falling-out with Tennessee. Despite making (allegedly) $2.4 million with his NIL deal, Iamaleava was seeking more than double that in a new deal. UT didn’t budge, and after skipping practice, coach Josh Heupel kicked him off the team. Iamaleava would return home to Cali after committing to UCLA in April, aiming to prove the mass doubters wrong.
Yet all he gave was a dud. The Bruins were thrashed in their home opener against Utah, 43-10. Not all of it is on Iamaleava, however; UCLA’s defense was PUTRID. The Utes amassed almost 500 total offensive yards and converted a staggering 14/16 on third downs. But that doesn’t mean Iamaleava is completely out of the woods. He completed 11/22 passes for 136 yards, a touchdown and an interception.
Definitely not the best start for a guy who made such a fuss about his monetary value that he ditched his team. He can rebound, but even though he may be able to change, that horrid defense isn’t going anywhere.
I ALMOST made a separate tier for K-State
I wouldn’t have considered Kansas State here if they lost to Iowa State. I mean, they lost 24-21 against a ranked Cyclones squad. That’s not too bad. But what came after is practically inexcusable. They had a chance to rebound smoothly at home against North Dakota, an FCS opponent.
But Kansas State just fell flat. They kept North Dakota in the game for far too long, falling behind in the fourth quarter 35-31 before Avery Johnson threw the winning touchdown to Joe Jackson with 42 seconds left. I just simply cannot gauge Kansas State; against Iowa State, their offense looked bad while their defense looked good. Yet we saw vice versa against North Dakota: good offense and bad defense. Not sure what we see next against Chris Klieman’s crew, but with how deep the Big 12 is this year, things are surely not looking up.
Army’s dream 2024 fades against the FCS
The Black Knights had an absolutely insane 2024, in just their first year in AAC. Led by Heisman candidate Bryson Daily, the team finished 12-2 with a conference championship. Had it not been for Boise State, we could’ve seen Army in the Playoff fold last year.
But now, with Daily gone, Army’s entering a refractory period under Jeff Monken. Usually, the military schools are always surprisingly solid or surprisingly bad. But the Black Knights started out terribly against FCS Tarleton State. The Texans prevailed 30-27 in double overtime; after Dawson Jones missed a field goal in second overtime, TSU kicker Brad Larson nailed the winning kick from 37 yards.
Considering Boise State’s huge loss to South Florida, the Group of Five is looking really bleak in terms of contenders, seeing as their top teams from last season both lost in sad fashion.
Questions for Week 2
How will Bryce Underwood fare in Norman?
Week 2 isn’t the most loaded in terms of marquee games. But the primetime Saturday matchup presents the biggest challenge for Michigan freshman quarterback Bryce Underwood. The former number-one overall recruit had a solid debut against New Mexico, completing 21/31 passes for 251 yards and a touchdown. He was helped out royally by transfer running back Justice Haynes, who had 16 carries for 159 yards and three touchdowns. Underwood will face a true test when the Wolverines travel to Norman to take on Oklahoma. The Sooners are led by transfer quarterback John Mateer, who completed 30/37 passes for 392 yards and three touchdowns with one interception. The Wolverine defense will have their hands full with Mateer, but I’ll be keeping my eye on how Underwood handles a raucous Oklahoma crowd.
Can South Florida make a G5 run?
The Bulls made a huge early Group of Five statement as they defeated #25 Boise State 34-7. Quarterback Byrum Brown passed for 210 yards while rushing for 43 yards and two touchdowns on the ground. They take on a huge challenge this weekend as they travel to the Swamp to take on #13 Florida, followed up by another huge matchup at Miami in Week 3. Most people would write off these teams, but USF has been a tough out for Power 4 teams. They gave Alabama a run for their money at home and on the road in 2023 and 2024, respectively. They also played a tough game against Miami and #1 pick Cam Ward at home.
Of course, playing on the road against these teams is much different, but considering the Bulls gave Alabama problems last season, you can’t exactly write off South Florida here. After smoking Boise State, how they perform in these next two matchups against the Gators and Hurricanes will hugely determine their season and outlook on the CFP.
Will UCLA rebound?
Nico Iamaleava’s new chapter has gotten off to a rocky start after their big loss at home to Utah. But the Bruins have a chance to ready the ship this week at UNLV. But the Rebels aren’t some pushovers; they’ve gone 2-0 against Idaho State and Sam Houston, both games scoring 38 points. Under new head coach Dan Mullen, the offensive trio of Anthony Colandrea, Jai’Den Thomas and Jaden Bradley present big problems for a UCLA defense that was carved to bits in Week 1.
However, UNLV’s defense has given up 26 points across those two contests, leaving the onus on Iamaleava to make up for the defensive woes. He has the potential to be the offensive takeover, but can he come through? If not, this season just got a whole lot more messy for Nico.
Does Jake Retzlaff continue his streak?
A crazy offseason for the former BYU quarterback, Retzlaff came under some heinous criminal accusations. While the civil lawsuit against him was dismissed, he would still be suspended by the university for violating the school’s honor code. Therefore, he decided to transfer, ending up at Tulane. Retzlaff immediately showed off why BYU was so high on people’s radars with him under center, as he threw for 152 yards and a touchdown while rushing for 113 yards and another touchdown in a 23-3 win over Northwestern. The Green Wave have been at the top of the Group of Five’s best for a few years now, and Retzlaff makes their path to a potential CFP spot a little more interesting. Retzlaff and Tulane return to action tomorrow night at South Alabama, then finishing their non-conference schedule at home against Duke and at Ole Miss. If Retzlaff keeps up this play, don’t doubt if the Green Wave crash the Playoff party for the Group of Five.
Leave a Reply